How to Cook an Outstanding Steak
Thaw it slowly, dry it well, salt it, sear it hot, check it with a thermometer, and let it rest. Those six steps matter more than any recipe.
Herd & Grace steaks are aged and then frozen at their peak, so a great steak starts with how you thaw it.
Plan ahead and thaw in the refrigerator for 12 to 24 hours, still sealed, on a rimmed dish. Spread multiple steaks out rather than stacking them. A slow thaw keeps the steak juicy and tender. Never thaw on the counter.
Before cooking, pat the steak completely dry and season generously with salt, either 45 minutes ahead or right before it goes in the pan. A dry surface is what gives you a deep brown crust.
Cook by temperature, not time. An instant-read thermometer is the single best tool for a perfect steak. Pull it about 5°F below your target, because it keeps cooking as it rests.
Rest it 5 to 10 minutes so the juices settle, then slice against the grain.
Steak doneness temperatures
| Rare | Pull at 115–120°F, about 120–125°F after resting. Cool red center |
|---|---|
| Medium-rare | Pull at 125–130°F, about 130–135°F after resting. Warm red center |
| Medium | Pull at 135–140°F, about 140–145°F after resting. Warm pink center |
| Medium-well | Pull at 145–150°F, about 150–155°F after resting. Slightly pink center |
| Well done | Pull at 155°F or above, 160°F+ after resting. No pink |
| Food safety | The USDA's safe minimum for whole cuts of beef is 145°F with a 3-minute rest |
The best method for each cut
| Filet mignon, New York strip, ribeye (1–1½ inches) | Pan sear in cast iron, finishing with butter, garlic and herbs, or grill over high heat. Filet recipe |
|---|---|
| Tomahawk, cowboy ribeye, porterhouse (2 inches and up) | Reverse sear: cook in a 225–275°F oven or the cool side of the grill to about 10–15°F below your target, then sear hard. Tomahawk recipe |
| Highly marbled Wagyu (MB 8 and above) | Hot pan, little or no oil, short cook. Serve in smaller portions. About marbling |
| Grass-fed beef | Leaner, so it cooks faster. Best rare to medium-rare; watch the thermometer closely |
| Skirt, hanger, bavette, asada | Very hot and very fast, then slice thinly against the grain. Skirt steak tacos |
| Tri-tip | Grill Santa Maria style or reverse sear, then slice against the grain, which changes direction partway through. Santa Maria tri-tip |